Madre's Missives


Inadvertent and Occasionally Intentional Thoughts

March 18th, 2005

Feminism in Islam

Posted At: 6:20pm by Sandra Ostapowich

Muslim Woman Plans to Lead Prayers, Sparking Controversy

In an attempt to bring attention to the second-class status that many Muslim women face, Amina Wadud, a leading female Islamic studies scholar and professor at Virginia Commonwealth University, will lead a prayer service in Manhattan. Three mosques refused to allow Wadud to lead the prayers, and a bomb threat caused the organizers of the service to change locations, reports the New York Times. The main organizer, Asra Q. Nomani, told the Times that they "are taking actions that no one else would have dared to think about before."

Several Muslim leaders have denounced women leading the Islamic services. Sheik Sayed Tantawi, the sheik of one of the world's top Islamic institutions in Cairo, Egypt, responded in the local Egyptian paper Al-Ahram, stating "a woman's body is private. When she leads men in prayer, in this case, it's not proper for them to look at the woman whose body is in front of them. Even if they see it in their daily life, it shouldn't be in situations of worship, where the main point is humility and modesty," reports the Associated Press .

Muslim women are generally not allowed under Islamic law to lead prayers in a mosque. Women are often made to pray in separate areas from the men or in another room altogether. Amina Wadud previously drew public attention when she entered her mosque in West Virginia through the men's front door and tried to pray with the men, according to the Times.


Do we have not ordain women for the same reason?  It is just too tempting for men to lust over a woman who is standing before them, leading them in prayer, so women should not do that?



Like a Prayer I am listening to Like a Prayer
Madonna
Release Date: 25 October, 1990
[ Printer Friendly Version ]


Comments

Re: Feminism in Islam

If, when you say that we ordain women for the same reason as the women feel like they want to prove something to the men, then absolutely.I think that women do that for that purpose, or for the fact that they dont know the scripture as well as they think that they do.

And i am not entirely sure that i understand the question if thats not anything close. :)

Re: Feminism in Islam

I was just asking if our reasoning was the same as the ones given by the Muslims - that women are too tempting and having a prayer led by one or having them even present in the same room for prayers is just too distracting for the men

Re: Feminism in Islam

ok. I'm not sure that that would be the same reason that we dont ordain women. I think that guys are pretty pathetic sometimes, but, in church? I guess it would be nice to think that they wouldnt do that. There are other places that they can go to be "guys". If they would chose to do such as thing as look at women that are "leaders" in the church, then they need help, because that it just sad.

Re: Feminism in Islam

ok. I'm not sure that that would be the same reason that we dont ordain women. I think that guys are pretty pathetic sometimes, but, in church? I guess it would be nice to think that they wouldnt do that. There are other places that they can go to be "guys". If they would chose to do such as thing as look at women that are "leaders" in the church, then they need help, because that it just sad.

Comment on entry entitled "Feminism in Islam"

You may use BBCode within your posts, a reference is available here.
Name: 
E-mail Address: 
Web Site: 
Subject: 

Notify me of replies to this comment.
Auth Code
Please type the letters in the image above:

E-mail Article
Send to:
From: