Madre's Missives


Inadvertent and Occasionally Intentional Thoughts

October 03rd, 2005

Pop Quiz

Posted At: 4:07am by Sandra Ostapowich

Everyone put down your books and take out a piece of paper and a pen. It's time for a quick pop quiz.  Just a simple true or false test.

When the term "domestic violence" comes up, many ideas come to mind.  A lot of the time, we aren't sure what to think, but usually have formulated some opinions about abuse already.  

How many of the following common beliefs regarding domestic abuse do you believe?  Which did you end up being mistaken about?  What was the most surprising to you?

1.    Domestic violence does not affect many Americans.

2.    Battering is only a momentary loss of temper.

3.    Stress causes battering.

4.    Drugs and alcohol cause the violence.

5.    Battered women provoke the violence.

6.    Only women are victims of domestic violence.

7.    The problem is couples assaulting each other.

8.    Domestic violence occurs only in poor urban areas.

9.    Domestic violence is a push, a slap, or a punch and does not produce serious injuries.

10.    It is easy for a battered woman to leave her abuser.

11.    Domestic violence does not affect children.

12.    After a woman leaves an abusive partner, the abuse stops.

13.    Batterers who seek custody do so out of love for their children and a desire to be good parents.

14.    Allegations of child abuse increase significantly in divorce and custody disputes; women frequently fabricate allegations of abuse to hurt their former partner or to gain an advantage in custody disputes.


1.    FALSE.  A woman is beaten every 15 seconds in the United States. Additionally, 63% of young men between the ages of 11 and 20 are serving time for homicide for killing their mother's abuser.

2.    FALSE.  Battering is the use of violence and other forms of abuse to establish control and power in a relationship. One in five female victims reports having been battered over and over again by the same person.

3.    FALSE.  Obviously some batterers experience stress, but stress does not cause abuse. Many men under severe stress do not batter. Even if the practitioner helps the batterer reduce his stress, the violence will continue or eventually resume because the batterer still feels entitled to assault his partner.

4.    FALSE.  Addictions are used as excuses to free the batterer from responsibility for the behavior. This theory does not explain why the batterer uses violence, why he targets a woman for abuse, nor why he batters when sober. The addictive batterer must be treated for two separate problems - his addiction and his violence. He will not necessarily stop battering if he gains control over his addiction.

5.    FALSE.  Any woman can find herself battered. The victim is not at fault but rather the batterer, the partner who has committed a crime. No one can be responsible for another person's deliberate choices and actions. Domestic violence victims, however, frequently hear comments from their abusers like, "I did it for your own good," or from outsiders, "You must have really made him mad." These statements can confuse a woman and lead her to take responsibility for the violence or blame herself. No matter what, domestic violence is not the victim's fault.

6.    FALSE.  Approximately 95% of those battered are women; however, in a small number of cases, women are the batterers and their male partners, the victims.

7.    FALSE.  Again, nearly ninety-five percent of victims are women. Although some women are violent to their partners - often even in self-defense - it is impossible to understand battering by counting up the number of times one person hits another. Domestic violence is a pattern of abuse in the attempt to increase power and control.

8.    FALSE.  Women of all cultures, races, occupations, incomes, and ages are battered by husbands, lovers, boyfriends, and partners. One in four pregnant women has a history of partner abuse.

9.    FALSE.  Battered women are often severely injured and even murdered. Between 22% and 35% of women who visit emergency rooms are there for injuries related to ongoing partner abuse.

10.    FALSE.  Women who leave their abuser are at 75% greater risk of being killed by the abuser than those who stay. Nationally, 50% of homeless women and children are on the street because of violence in their home.

11.    FALSE.  Child abuse occurs in up to 70% of the homes where domestic violence occurs. When a parent is victimized by domestic violence, children are abused at a rate 15 times the national average.

12.    FALSE.  Separated women are three times more likely than divorced women, and 25 times more likely than married women living with their husbands, to be victimized by a batterer. Batterers frequently take advantage of court-ordered visitation to inflict harm on their former partners and their children.

13.    FALSE.  Custody litigation frequently becomes a vehicle whereby batterers attempt to extend or maintain their control and authority over the abused parent after separation. Fathers who battered the mother are twice as likely to seek sole physical custody for their children than are non-violent fathers.

14.    FALSE.  Allegations of child sexual abuse are rare, occurring in only 2-3% of all divorce cases and fewer than 10% of custody cases. Less than 1/2 of all allegations of abuse against fathers are made by the child's mother, most are made by third parties. Allegations of child sexual abuse are not more likely to be false when made during custody/divorce proceedings than when made at other times.



Edited on: October 03rd, 2005 4:13 am
[ Printer Friendly Version ]


Comments

Re: Pop Quiz

Madre,

It is essential when such a serious topic is at hand that statistics are vetted for accuracy. It seems that perhaps, in your deep concern for those who are abused and to raise our awareness of the problem, you've missed on a few of your numbers.

I don't know your source for the statistics in the post. However, I am broadly aware that the statement, "A woman is beaten every 15 seconds in the United States," is misleading at best. The book Behind Closed Doors: Violence in the American Family seems to have the only source data for this claim, even though it is sometimes attributed to the FBI. However, the same data in the same book, claims that a man is beated every 15 seconds as well.

In fact, while the myths and facts presented above suggest that women are more likely victims of domestic violence than men, a study published in Criminology and Public Policy in 2001 showed that women were as least as likely to initiated domestic violence as men.

It gets worse. The common perception is that women sustain more severe injuries from domestic violence than men, because men are on average larger and stronger. However, a tudy reported in the Annals of Emergency Medicine and reviewed in the Journal of the American Medical Association states that half of the domestic violence injuries encountered in a large urban emergency room were sustained by men. Data from additional studies indicates that women are more likely to use weapons in these kinds of attacks than men.

As to violent fathers being twice as likely to seek sole custody as non-violent fathers, statistics state that 7% of batterers seek any form of custody. So, unless the non-violent fathers seek sole-custody at a rate below 3.5%, that seems to be in error as well.

There seems to be little likelihood that the statement, "63% of young men between the ages of 11 and 20 are serving time for homicide for killing their mother's abuser," is true either. Statistics of this sort are simply not kept. To substantiate the claim, one would need to know the victim-offender relationship in each murder committed by a juvenile, whose name would be difficult to obtain; and then cross-check that with tens of thousands of reports of assaults on women whose names might be different from their sons'. The FBI does not do this, nor does the Bureau of Justice Statistics. It is doubtful that there is any basis in fact for the claim.

Finally, the post repeats the oft-heard claim, "Between 22% and 35% of women who visit emergency rooms are there for injuries related to ongoing partner abuse." Again, this is simply not true. As Christina Hoff Sommers showed in her book, Who Stole Feminism?, Department of Justice statistics reveal that less than one percent of the women who visit emergency
rooms do so as a result of domestic violence.

Domestic violence is serious issue, whether men beat women or women beat men or adults beat children or children beat adults. However, salacious statistics when false do little to encourage serious discussion. Instead, nebulous numbers tend to cast the whole question in the light of feminist crys about the savagery of men. That won't raise awareness.

-Pastor Fickel

Re: Pop Quiz

As I have written in my new post, the point of this post was not necessarily to throw out "salacious statistics" but to dispell many myths surrounding abuse. The new post lays out more statistics with citations for them.

Re: Pop Quiz

Men would not beat women if women knew thier place, but no some lesbian had to stand up for womens rights......Now, we think we rule the world and have just as much rights as men!!!! it will never be that way!!! anytime that i get out of line my boyfriend has no problem with bending me over his knee and putting a belt to my butt...however, it may seem cruel but im a much happier person knowing that the weight of the world is on his shoulders not mine

Re: Pop Quiz

Men would not beat women if women knew thier place, but no some lesbian had to stand up for womens rights......Now, we think we rule the world and have just as much rights as men!!!! it will never be that way!!! anytime that i get out of line my boyfriend has no problem with bending me over his knee and putting a belt to my butt...however, it may seem cruel but im a much happier person knowing that the weight of the world is on his shoulders not mine


I agree with you that women are not meant to be "equal" to men, clearly they are "meant" to be more important than men. A husband is given to serve His wife as Christ served the church. He is to be Christ for her (Eph. 5).

Her "submission" is to receive her husband as Christ. She is to receive him doing everything--even giving His own life--for her.

With the husband serving the wife and the wife submitting to her husband - what a happy world that is! When everyone submits to one another out of fear and reverence for Christ, what a wonderful life we have!

The weight of the world is not on your shoulders, but on Christ's. It's very good that your boyfriend other carries that weight. The question is ... how is a man hitting his girlfriend/wife being CHRIST for her? How is he serving her as Christ does the church? How is he washing her sins away? How is he cleansing her?

Is that what Christ does for us? Is that how Christ puts us in our place?

No, He takes our place, takes upon Himself the abuse and scorn that we deserve and dies for us. He doesn't abuse us, but dies in our place. Him for us, as if He is the lesser and we are the greater.

What is the "proper" place of women? Her place is to be served by her husband.



Re: Pop Quiz

Men do not beat women to keep them in their place. It is not a "woman's place" to live in fear of beatings and other threats of violence from someone who is given to love and care for her and consider her more important than himself. That just is not how you treat someone you love.

Your boyfriend has no business taking you over his knee and taking a belt to your behind. You are not a child he is given to discipline (not that I think this is an appropriate way to discipline a child either). Also, he is just a boyfriend, temporary dating relationship. He does not even have the authority of a husband in a marital relationship to whom you are given to submit, nor is he responsible to God for you.

Ashlee, if what you post is indeed true, you are being used and abused by your boyfriend. Get away, talk to your parents, talk to your pastor, get some help. You are one for whom Christ died, and you are given to be loved, not controlled by another through fear.

Comment on entry entitled "Pop Quiz"

You may use BBCode within your posts, a reference is available here.
Name: 
E-mail Address: 
Web Site: 
Subject: 

Notify me of replies to this comment.
Auth Code
Please type the letters in the image above:

E-mail Article
Send to:
From: